TMZ has obtained concert footage from R. Kelly's 2016 show in New Jersey as he was touring in promotion of his album "The Buffet." This video was shot in October of that year, and you can see Joycelyn Savage, Dominique Gardner and Azriel Clary standing right next to each other right at the bottom of the stage ... in clear view of Kelly.
TMZ has consistently been credited for breaking the biggest stories dominating the entertainment news landscape and changed the way the public gets their news. Regularly referenced by the media, TMZ is one of the most cited entertainment news sources in the world.
Subscribe to TMZ on YouTube for breaking celebrity news/ gossip and insight from the newsroom staff (TMZ Chatter & TMZ News), the best clips from TMZ on TV, Raw & Uncut TMZ paparazzi video (from TMZ.com) and the latest video from TMZ Sports and TMZ Live!
Keeping Up with Our YouTube Exclusive Content:
TMZ Chatter: TMZ newsroom staff insight and commentary from stories/ photos/ videos on TMZ.com
TMZ News: The latest news you need to know from TMZ.com
Raq Rants: Raquel Harper talks to a celebrity guest with ties to the hip hop and R&B communities.
Behind The Bar Podcast: TMZ's lawyers Jason Beckerman and Derek Kaufman loiter at the intersection of law and entertainment, where they look closely at the personalities, events and trends driving the world of celebrity — and how the law affects it all.
We love Hollywood, we just have a funny way of showing it.
Need More TMZ?
TMZ Website: http://po.st/TMZWebsite
LIKE TMZ on Facebook! http://po.st/TMZLike
FOLLOW TMZ on Twitter! http://po.st/TMZFollow
FOLLOW TMZ on Instagram! http://po.st/TMZInsta
TMZ on TV & TMZ Sports on FS1 Tune In Info: http://po.st/TMZOnAir
TMZ is on iOS! http://po.st/TMZiOS
TMZ is on Android! http://po.st/TMZonAndroid
Got a Tip?
Contact TMZ: http://po.st/TMZTip
Check out TMZ Live, TMZ Sports and toofab!
TMZ Live: http://po.st/TMZLiveWebsite
Subscribe! TMZ Live: http://po.st/TMZLiveSubscribe
TMZ Sports: http://po.st/TMZSportsWebsite
Subscribe! TMZ Sports: http://po.st/TMZSportsSubscribe
Subscribe! toofab: http://po.st/toofabSubscribe
Warren Jeffs' cult members also adored him, cried for him and defended him. Believed every word he said. Many abused by Jeffs still defend him, I don't know what part of "cult" and "brainwashed" people don't get. Also they can only say and do what he tells them to, so of course they'll cheer and look happy because he told them to do that. But they are so mind controlled and they are afraid of each other! When Dominique ran away she was terrified of Jocellyn. They are never alone in public, always in pairs or groups... they are paranoid about each other probably.
SO WHAT SHE DID WAS GET R KELLY ATTENTION ECT TO TELL HIM THAT THE PERSON WAS VIDEOTAPE THEM ALL IN THAT CORNER...AND THATS WHEN SHE POINTED THAT PERSON OUT AND R KELLY WALKED OVER AND GOT ONE OF HIS STAFF TO REMOVE THAT PERSON OUT THE BUILDING..BECAUSE SOME OF TEM GIRLS WERE UNDERAGE THAN...AND HE WAS TRYIN TO GET MORE GIRLS THAT NIGHT
They are in baggy sweat suits with hats on. 🤔 a claim that victims have said that r kelly had them wear.. azriel points out the women filming, r kelly approaches and gets his security guard and puts a shirt over the camera🤔 then video cuts... nope this does not look suspicious at all ( sarcasm)....
That's what he did with his other girl friend. He handcuff her in the middle of the show. Acting like she was just part of the audience. The only reason he didn't end up doing the same thing to those girls is bc they look and are to young.
Those girls were not being held hostage nor brainwashed. They were enjoying the lifestyle. They looked totally normal. Dammit if I was 17-18 no job and had parents that didn’t give a damn and Could ride this mans coat tail and be taken care of and had front row seats to concerts I would enjoy it as well. What happened was when Kelly stopped giving some of these girls that 5k a month that’s when they wanted to expose him and write a book and do interviews. It’s all about the money. You all get be fooled by these women if you want to. These women been in the streets for a long time they know the game they are “street” smart. They’ll play you too.
Off course these girls are cheering ... this is the one part of the “living with r [email protected] they enjoy and love ... but in their house we all know that’s the situation was and is abusive so please 🛑
The parents stopped getting paid and they got mad and went on a slander spree... Andreas' lying ass and the rest of those lying mfs all are broke and are trying to extort him but they've did so much damage the man can't work anymore... Regardless of his past he doesn't deserve this because since that first trial I haven't heard of him doing anything since... I hope he beat these charges and sue lifetime, the parents, the accusers, and ANDREA!!!
I have one question for all of you: Although none of us will ever know the full truth, with all of the evidence, VIDEO evidence at that, would YOU feel safe with your daughter in a room alone with R Kelly? If the answer is not a resounding yes for any reason, say less. Wisdom is with the shrewd.
@timsavage joycelyn not coming back to you you and your wife made this thing into a circus she knows how the real story goes she knows the lies she’s not a girl she’s a woman she rather stay away then come back to your circus she knows you’ll only further exploit the situation with interviews reports and money making schemes xucking frauds
What do people fail to realize is that this is when these young women were first introduced to R Kelly not Robert Kelly... So if this was one of your daughters that had gone a miss under the influence of a grown ass man ------- When they were a minor ?
You would be okay cuz your daughter was a little hoe??? Some of y'all just need to shut the hell up and close your mouths.... A child is a freaking child anyway you want to slice the cake they're not capable of making sound rational decisions... Any parent with a grain of salt or worth their weight would know that !!!! SMFH
My husband and I talk about the difference between Hugh Heffner and R. Kelly all the time. The difference is that even though Hugh had young ladies around him also, he at least made sure these ladies were well taken care of. That is the difference. These ladies report that R Kelly starves them and makes them wear oversized baggy sweats... just like how the girls are dressed in this video. Look at how well everyone else is dressed compared to R Kelly's girls. They look crazy. With Hugh... his young ladies were free to dress how they please and look beautiful.... they ate well.. they were featured in his magazines and paid very well and when they left Hugh Heffner, they returned more wealthy than before. With R Kelly, these girls return home to their mommas with serious mental issues, weight loss and broke as hell. You can even see that the young lady Azriel is missing a damn nail. Point is, if a man is going to have young ladies... he should take good care of them and set them up for life. R Kelly is instead setting young ladies up with herpes and trauma.
You actually wrong
Hugh had curfew for all of them
And it was mandatory he had sex with them.
Also they made A 2k A month.
Oh may I add
He used them as Prostitutes to have sex with stars and so on
He also had A girl 10 years old pose nude for his playboy magazine
The different between the two
R.kelly was messing with Black girls/women
Hugh only liked white women because they're not big mouths like black women and quick to tell
Oh yeah, because when you being held against your will and taken to a crowded venue with thousands of people, you don’t run, you don’t slip notes to people, you go on camera happy, smiling, joking. Yeah, I’m sure that’s how I’d react if kidnapped and held against my will and beat and rapped. NOT!
Bottom line i dont believe one of them woman is a slave accept for Dominique...he did her wrong she was unrecognized with joecelyn savage on tmz...her MOM WENT & GOT HER..GLAD SHE HOME NOW THE REST OF THEM WILLINGLY STAYED & GET THE COME UP GLITCH & GLAMMER HE CAN PROVIDES ANT NOTHING SLOW ABOUT THESE WOMAN...THEY SEE HIS 💰& FAME SO WANT TO STAY..LITTLE DO THEY KNOW HES GONNA FIND SOMEONE TO REPLACE THEY ASS CAUSE THEY GETTING OLDER...HE LIKES YOUNG CHICKS
In the documentary the most recent girl that was introduced to Joycelyn in her hotel room by R.Kelly noticed that when he came into the room she jumped up “like a puppy” and kissed on the lips him to greet him and that when he said anything she’d laugh hysterically like he was he most hilarious person ever to her and she just looked at him in awe and as soon as he left the room she would go back to sitting down acting numb and not saying a word. People who are saying they’re fine and choosing this life because they look happy here don’t get that they are brainwashed - he chooses when he wants them to be happy and when to fear him. He’s me talking controlling them. 😰The only man they “know know” now is him.
What was the person in the video yelling? Sounded like she keeps saying “wipe yourself off you’re a man, you’re a grown man.” Then when Azriel pointed at her someone says “let’s go ma’am”. Also, somebody was arguing in the comments on another video that Azriel is fine because she was just in a video dancing on the side of the stage? Is there a different video because this one says 2016. That’s 3 years ago... just like her family said they haven’t seen her in 3 years.
Everyone in this Hollywood business are paedophiles. All the producers an directors an everyone. It's one big cult. Sadly this wont stop. They are very wealthy people and think they can do anything to anyone. SPEAK UP PEOPLE DONT BE AFRAID
Ok! Well they happy. Wtf these girls n their parents knew wtf was going on. They let them do wutever cuz they knew he was famous n rich... and he paid their asses! He didn’t just snatched them n shit. It’s just so damn stupid. Yes it’s nasty. But their parents allowed it.
I'm so glad to see the 50/50 opinion. I agree the culture vulturing is real on this brother. If it was some American muslim arranging to marry his teen daughter and most likely they aren't willing. Or these so called Amish families and their polygamy with teen wives/moms..probably walking around with herpes too. But Kellz' hoes is being PAID with luxuries...Parents etc benefited at some point before he ASKED these girls to make a choice. Unless I see a dungeon with females chained or wearing dirty draws..then this is just his private sexual desires. No DIFFERENT FROM ALL THE THOUSANDS OF PORN. No different than a young rapper beating up his 16 yr old girlfriend...shaming her in front of groupie hoes..expecting her to accept your sloppy dick leftovers..because she got that Gucci bag he let her order otw in the mail..what makes this difft from other sexual allegations is they weren't drugged and woke up in a taxi not knowing what happened..he's not like Cosby. He talked to these girls FULLY and I'm sure if they said take me home He would eventually oblige. But CULTURALLY ( to most men) they don't want a woman to stray to other men especially after sex. Especially if you choosing your females carefully. The same reason any NON AMERICAN CULTURE views young wives..Unfortunately the black men here in America are called pimps...but pimps make money off ALL their women. A man will TAKE CARE of his woman Women, watever. I can't talk bad on him until I see abuse..whether we can accept LIFE OR NOT many teens involved in the hiphop culture are sexually active. And want to find that older man who is caring (like a dad) and will mold them the way they want. Some teen girls DON'T WANT GUYS THEIR AGE because they don't have money. They play too much and don't appreciate a woman sexually..and even though we are finding out now he's bisexual. He was always that way before fame. Aaliyah allowed herself to learn sexually from that man...UNTIL I SEE ABUSE..THEN IT'S ALL BLACKMAIL..Pissing is a fetish...playing with feces..all that...and them hoes get paid good money for porn..NOT GUILTY UNTIL CHILD PORN IS PROVEN...
Y’all r stupid. This is for show. He knows that it’s been televised that these girls families have been looking for them. If people see on camera then being regular it makes the parents look crazy. I cannot believe you guys falling for this. He would be an idiot to keep them in hiding with their faces plastered all over everywhere. 🤦🏾♀️
My kingdom for your Bee Saving Paper says the queen. This biodegradable paper becomes an “energy drink” for bees. To attract them, the paper contains a paste made from the same form of energy-rich glucose that beekeepers use during the … Read More.
A Futuristic Self-Contained Eco-Village of Homes Enclosed in Greenhouses.
Imagine living in a self-sustaining eco-village of homes enclosed in greenhouses?
A new community in the Netherlands will harness the latest technologies to create a closed-loop system that will produce its own solar and biogas power, grow organic vegetables,
New High-Tech Air Conditioned Jackets Keep Japanese Gardeners Cool in Summer Heat.
Excessive heat can cause both plants and gardeners to wilt. While a hat and a wet bandana can help during the hot summers months, some gardeners are keeping cool with new high-tech air-conditioned jackets.
In Kagoshima, Japan, scorching summer temperatures … Read More.
Hive Five for Largest Solar Farm Apiary in America.
The largest solar farm apiary in America will come alive at Old Sol Apiaries in Oregon, with 48 hives arriving on the site just in time for National Pollinator Week, June 18-22.
Old Sol’s founder, John Jacob, says that the … Read More.
Farmerettes: Women Who Farmed and Gardened for Victory.
They were known as “farmerettes”–the hard working women on the home front who mobilized by the thousands to fill agricultural labor shortages during the First and Second World Wars. On big farms and in small Victory Gardens, they challenged conventional … Read More.
26 Last Minute Home and Garden Mother’s Day Gifts.
It’s not too late to celebrate your cultivated Mom with these last minute Mother’s Day gardening gifts for the gardener!
1. Monticello Gardener’s Gift Basket From the shop of Thomas Jefferson’s plantation residence, Monticello, comes this artfully arranged keepsake basket … Read More.